Moons vs planets
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Defining Moons and Planets: Key Differences and Similarities
Moons and planets are both major types of celestial bodies in our solar system, but they differ in several fundamental ways. Planets are primary bodies that orbit a star, like the Sun, while moons (also called natural satellites) are objects that orbit planets or other non-stellar bodies 14. The International Astronomical Union (IAU) defines a planet as a body that orbits the Sun, is spherical due to its own gravity, and has cleared its orbital neighborhood. Moons do not meet all these criteria, as they orbit planets rather than the Sun directly 5.
Formation and Types of Moons and Planets
Planet and Moon Formation Processes
Planets form from the accumulation of material in a protoplanetary disk around a young star, while moons can form in several ways. Regular moons typically form from the circumplanetary disk of gas and dust around a planet, as a by-product of the planet’s own formation. Irregular moons, on the other hand, are often captured objects from regions like the asteroid belt or Kuiper Belt, and have more distant, inclined, and elliptical orbits 2. Transitional moons, such as Saturn’s Iapetus, have characteristics between regular and irregular moons. Some planets also have ring moons, which are found at the edges of planetary rings 2.
Internal Structure and Composition
Both planets and moons can have complex internal structures. Earth-like planets and many large moons have iron-rich cores, silicate mantles, and crusts. Some icy moons have a core, a mantle, and an outer layer of water ice, sometimes with subsurface oceans. However, the proportions of metal, rock, and ice can vary greatly between planets and moons. For example, the Moon has a much smaller core relative to its size compared to Mercury 3. The processes that shape their interiors—such as heat transport, volcanism, and magnetic field generation—are similar, but the details and outcomes differ 34.
Orbital Dynamics and Gravitational Influence
Orbits and Gravitational Spheres
Planets orbit stars, while moons orbit planets within a region called the Hill Sphere, which is the area where a planet’s gravity dominates over the Sun’s. The size of a planet’s Hill Sphere determines how many moons it can capture or retain 2. Some planets also have asteroids trapped at stable Lagrange points (L4 and L5), known as Trojans 2.
Tidal Interactions and Evolution
Tidal forces between planets and their moons can significantly affect their orbits, spins, and even internal heating. For example, tidal dissipation in giant planets like Saturn can cause their moons to migrate outward over time. The rate and nature of this migration depend on the planet’s internal structure and the mechanisms of tidal dissipation 10. In some cases, resonance locking can occur, where a moon’s orbit becomes synchronized with oscillations in the planet, leading to enhanced migration 10.
Special Cases and Classification Debates
There is ongoing debate about the classification of certain large moons. For instance, the Earth-Moon system has been described as a “double planet” because the Moon is relatively large compared to Earth. Some argue that the Moon meets all the IAU’s criteria for a planet, except that it orbits Earth rather than the Sun, and suggest new definitions such as “satellite planet” or “double planet” to better describe such systems 5. Similarly, Pluto and its moon Charon are sometimes considered a “double dwarf planet” system 5.
Moons and Planets Beyond the Solar System
The processes that form moons and planets are expected to occur in other planetary systems as well. However, the formation of large moons around large planets may be rare, as simulations suggest that vapor-rich disks around large planets are not conducive to forming fractionally large moons. This may explain why Earth’s Moon is unusually large compared to its planet, and why large exomoons have not yet been confirmed 6. Additionally, planetary migration can lead to the loss of moons, especially if the planet moves inward toward its star, as resonant interactions can destabilize moon orbits 7.
Conclusion
Moons and planets are distinct but related types of celestial bodies, differing mainly in what they orbit and how they form. While planets are primary bodies orbiting stars, moons are secondary bodies orbiting planets, with a wide variety of origins, compositions, and evolutionary paths. Their interactions, both gravitational and tidal, shape their long-term evolution and the architecture of planetary systems 123410. Ongoing research continues to refine our understanding of these fascinating objects and their roles in the cosmos.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic