Oil prices and stock market correlation
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Time-Varying Correlation Between Oil Prices and Stock Markets
Research consistently shows that the correlation between oil prices and stock markets is not fixed; it changes over time and depends on various factors such as the type of economy (oil-importing vs. oil-exporting), market conditions, and global events like financial crises or pandemics. For example, studies using advanced models like DCC-GARCH and wavelet analysis find that the relationship between oil prices and stock markets can shift from negative to positive, especially during periods of economic turmoil such as the 2008 financial crisis or the COVID-19 pandemic, when correlations tend to increase, indicating contagion effects between the two markets 124510.
Oil-Importing vs. Oil-Exporting Countries: Correlation Differences
The impact of oil price changes on stock markets is stronger and more direct in oil-exporting countries compared to oil-importing countries. In oil-exporting nations, stock markets are more sensitive to oil price movements, and oil prices often lead stock market returns. In contrast, oil-importing countries experience a weaker but still significant relationship, with oil sometimes acting as a safe haven or hedge asset 1258.
Asymmetry and Nonlinearity in Oil-Stock Market Relationships
The relationship between oil prices and stock markets is often asymmetric and nonlinear. Stock markets tend to react more strongly to negative oil price shocks than to positive ones, and the direction and strength of the correlation can change depending on whether the market is experiencing high or low returns or volatility. Nonlinear causality has been observed, with bidirectional effects in some markets and unidirectional effects in others, depending on the type of oil (WTI or Brent) and the development level of the stock market (developed, emerging, or frontier) 56710.
Volatility Spillovers and Connectedness
Oil price volatility is a key driver of stock market volatility, with spillover effects that are especially pronounced during periods of market stress. The transmission of shocks is generally from oil markets to stock markets, and the degree of connectedness increases during crises. Oil price volatility can have both negative and positive impacts on stock returns, depending on the prevailing market conditions and the level of volatility in both markets 378.
Implications for Investors and Policymakers
These findings have important implications for portfolio diversification, risk management, and policy decisions. Investors should consider the time-varying, asymmetric, and nonlinear nature of the oil-stock market relationship when developing investment strategies. Policymakers need to be aware of the potential for increased market connectedness and contagion during periods of high oil price volatility or global crises 1356810.
Conclusion
The correlation between oil prices and stock markets is complex, dynamic, and influenced by a range of economic and market factors. It varies across countries, market conditions, and over time, with stronger effects observed during periods of crisis and in oil-exporting economies. Understanding these patterns is crucial for effective investment and policy decisions.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic