Open carry laws and rates of violent crime
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Overview of Open Carry (Right-to-Carry) Laws and Violent Crime Rates
Open carry and right-to-carry (RTC) laws, which allow individuals to carry firearms in public, have been the subject of extensive research regarding their impact on violent crime rates. The findings across studies are mixed, with some research suggesting a decrease in violent crime, while more recent and methodologically advanced studies indicate an increase or no significant effect.
Studies Reporting Decreases in Violent Crime After RTC Laws
Early research, notably by Lott and Mustard, found that the adoption of RTC laws was associated with significant reductions in violent crime rates, including murder, rape, and robbery. For example, one study reported that six years after RTC laws were enacted, murder rates fell by 9%, rape by 11%, and robbery by 7% 110. These findings contributed to the "more guns, less crime" hypothesis.
Studies Challenging Crime-Reducing Effects of RTC Laws
However, subsequent analyses have raised concerns about the robustness of these early findings. Some researchers found that the results were highly sensitive to model specifications and sample choices. For instance, when Florida was excluded from the analysis, no detectable impact of RTC laws on murder and rape rates was found, and more general models showed no significant effect on any type of violent crime . Other critiques argue that the conclusions of crime reduction are unwarranted and not supported by more comprehensive data or improved methodologies .
Evidence Linking RTC Laws to Increases in Violent Crime
More recent and comprehensive studies using advanced statistical techniques and longer timeframes have found that RTC laws are associated with increases in violent crime. For example, analyses using state panel data and synthetic control methods show that RTC laws are linked to a 13-15% increase in violent crime rates ten years after adoption 58. Another study using marginal structural models found that RTC laws significantly increase violent crime by 7.5%, including higher rates of murder, robbery, and aggravated assault . Research focusing on large urban centers found that RTC laws increased violent crime by 20% in cities with populations over 250,000, with additional effects such as increased gun theft and lower crime clearance rates .
Mixed or Nuanced Findings
Some studies suggest that the effects of RTC laws may vary by crime type and over time. For example, one analysis found no significant overall effect on violent or property crime rates but did observe short-term increases in robbery and medium-term decreases in murder rates . Additionally, spatial spillover effects were noted, where changes in crime rates in neighboring states influenced local crime rates.
Conclusion
The relationship between open carry (right-to-carry) laws and violent crime rates is complex and remains debated. While early studies suggested that RTC laws reduce violent crime, more recent and methodologically rigorous research generally finds that these laws are associated with increases in violent crime, particularly in large urban areas. Some studies find no significant effect or nuanced impacts depending on the type of crime and timeframe. Overall, the current body of evidence leans toward RTC laws contributing to higher rates of violent crime, though the magnitude and mechanisms may vary by context 1345+4 MORE.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic