Price to earnings ratio with negative earnings
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Understanding Price-to-Earnings (P/E) Ratio with Negative Earnings
The price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio is a widely used financial metric that compares a company’s stock price to its earnings per share. However, when a company reports negative earnings (a net loss), the P/E ratio becomes problematic or even meaningless, as dividing by a negative number does not provide a useful valuation metric .
Negative Earnings and the P/E Ratio: Interpretation Challenges
When earnings are negative, the P/E ratio can turn negative or be undefined, making it difficult for investors to interpret or compare across companies. Research shows that the traditional assumption of a positive and consistent price-earnings relationship does not hold for firms with losses. In fact, for loss-making firms, there can be an anomalous negative price-earnings relation, which is often due to omitted variables that are positively correlated with stock price but negatively correlated with current earnings, such as the book value of equity or the potential for an earnings turnaround .
The Role of Book Value and Other Variables
Including additional variables like the beginning-of-year book value of equity in valuation models can eliminate the negative price-earnings relation for loss firms. This suggests that the simple earnings capitalization model is misspecified for companies with negative earnings, and that book value of equity is a more relevant measure in these cases . This adjustment helps provide a more accurate picture of firm value when earnings are negative.
Predictive Power of Negative Earnings Components
Interestingly, research on the S&P 500 index finds that the negative component of the earnings-price ratio (i.e., firms with negative earnings) has the most predictive ability for future stock returns and earnings growth. This means that, to the extent that earnings-price yields predict future returns, the negative earnings component is a key driver .
Investor Behavior and Market Reactions
The reporting and dissemination of P/E ratios, especially for firms with high or negative P/E values, can influence investor attention and behavior. Media coverage of P/E ratios helps investors compare companies more easily, but it can also foster short-termism and increased focus on earnings, even when those earnings are negative .
Conclusion
In summary, the P/E ratio loses its traditional meaning when earnings are negative, and relying solely on this metric can be misleading. For loss-making firms, investors and analysts should consider additional variables such as book value of equity and the potential for earnings recovery. Moreover, the negative earnings component of the earnings-price ratio can provide valuable predictive insights for future returns. Adjusting valuation models to account for these factors leads to a more accurate assessment of company value in the presence of negative earnings 123.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic