Protein shake sweeteners and health effects
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Protein Shake Sweeteners: Types and Health Effects
Types of Sweeteners in Protein Shakes
Protein shakes can be sweetened with a variety of ingredients, including traditional sugars (like glucose and fructose), artificial sweeteners (such as sucralose), and newer alternatives like sweet proteins (e.g., brazzein, monellin, MNEI) 368. Sweet proteins are gaining attention as they offer high sweetness with little to no calories and do not raise blood sugar levels 368.
Glycemic Response and Blood Sugar Control
The choice of sweetener in protein shakes can significantly affect blood sugar levels. Traditional sugars like glucose and fructose cause a noticeable increase in blood glucose and insulin levels after consumption, which can impact energy regulation and satiety 15. In contrast, sweet proteins and non-nutritive sweeteners do not raise blood sugar, making them suitable for people with diabetes or those aiming to control their glycemic response 3568.
Metabolic and Health Benefits of Sweet Proteins
Sweet proteins, such as MNEI and brazzein, have shown promising health effects in animal studies. For example, replacing fructose with the sweet protein MNEI in a high-fat diet improved insulin sensitivity, reduced inflammation, and prevented metabolic disturbances in rats . Safety studies on brazzein indicate it is non-allergenic, non-genotoxic, and safe for consumption at levels much higher than typical dietary intake . Reviews also highlight that sweet proteins do not contribute to dental caries and may help with weight control due to their low calorie content 36.
Appetite, Satiety, and Food Intake
The type of sweetener can influence appetite and subsequent food intake. Shakes sweetened with traditional sugars may increase the desire to eat more, especially if the product is perceived as healthy, potentially leading to higher calorie intake later . Non-nutritive sweeteners and sweet proteins, which do not provide energy, have less impact on brain regions related to reward and satiety, possibly helping to reduce overall calorie consumption .
Consumer Perceptions and Acceptance
Consumers are increasingly interested in healthier and more natural alternatives to sugar. Products sweetened with sweet proteins are generally viewed more favorably when their health benefits are emphasized, especially among individuals concerned about sugar intake and weight management . However, the perception of naturalness and the emotional response of guilt can also influence acceptance and preference for these products .
Safety and Long-Term Considerations
Current evidence suggests that sweet proteins like brazzein are safe for use in food and beverages, with no observed adverse effects in animal studies . However, more long-term human studies are needed to fully understand their safety and health impacts 36. Artificial sweeteners are also considered safe within recommended limits, but their long-term effects remain a topic of ongoing research .
Conclusion
The choice of sweetener in protein shakes can have important effects on blood sugar, metabolism, appetite, and overall health. Sweet proteins offer a promising alternative to traditional sugars and artificial sweeteners, providing sweetness without calories or glycemic impact. While current research supports their safety and potential health benefits, further studies are needed to confirm their long-term effects in humans. Consumer acceptance is influenced by perceptions of healthiness and naturalness, making clear communication about the benefits of sweet protein-based products important for their success.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic