Redshift and big bang theory
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Redshift and Big Bang Theory: A Comprehensive Analysis
Introduction to Redshift and Big Bang Theory
The concept of redshift is pivotal in understanding the Big Bang theory and the expanding universe. Redshift refers to the phenomenon where light from distant galaxies shifts towards the red end of the spectrum, indicating that these galaxies are moving away from us. This observation has been a cornerstone in supporting the Big Bang theory, which posits that the universe began from an extremely hot and dense state and has been expanding ever since.
Alternative Explanations for Redshift
Dispersive Extinction Theory
One alternative explanation for redshift is the Dispersive Extinction Theory (DET). This theory suggests that cosmic redshift and the 2.7 K background radiation are due to the dispersive scattering and absorption of starlight by the space medium, rather than the Doppler effect caused by the receding movement of stars and galaxies . Proponents of DET argue that the Big Bang theory faces several fundamental difficulties, such as the violation of conservation laws of mass and energy, and the need for unobservable dark matter.
Tired Light Theories
Tired light theories propose that the redshift-distance relationship can be explained by the gradual loss of energy of photons as they travel through space, rather than the expansion of the universe. These theories suggest that light from distant objects gets "tired" and loses energy, resulting in a redshift. However, these theories have been largely discredited because they would cause blurring of distant objects, which is not observed.
Testing the Redshift-Scale Factor Relation
The canonical redshift-scale factor relation, (1/a = 1 + z), is a fundamental element in the standard cosmological model. This relation assumes a homogeneous and isotropic universe described by the Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker metric. Any deviation from this assumption could yield a different mapping between the model redshift and the observed redshift. Recent studies using baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) and Type Ia supernova data have shown that the generalized redshift mapping is strongly degenerated with dark energy, indicating that current data do not constrain dark energy unless BAO data include measurements from the Lyα forest of high-redshift quasars.
Challenges to the Big Bang Theory
Inhomogeneous Cosmological Models
In inhomogeneous cosmological models, the redshift from the Big Bang can be infinite, but infinite blueshifts are also possible. To avoid divergent energy fluxes, it is required that realistic cosmological models must not display infinite blueshifts. This requirement has been applied to the Tolman model, concluding that the bang time must be simultaneous, and the only acceptable model that is homogeneous at late times is the Robertson-Walker model.
Observational Anomalies
Astronomical observations have shown numerous exceptions to the general redshift of electromagnetic radiation, such as the existence of blueshifted radiation, which indicates an approach of stars and galaxies. These anomalies, along with anisotropies in the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation (CMBR), pose significant challenges to the Big Bang theory and the isotropic expansion of the universe.
Conclusion
While the redshift phenomenon has been a crucial piece of evidence supporting the Big Bang theory, alternative explanations and challenges continue to emerge. The Dispersive Extinction Theory and tired light theories offer different perspectives on the cause of redshift, though they face significant criticisms. Testing the redshift-scale factor relation and addressing observational anomalies are essential for refining our understanding of the universe's expansion. As research progresses, it is crucial to consider both conventional and alternative models to develop a more comprehensive cosmological theory.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic