Substance abuse evaluation
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Substance Abuse Evaluation: Key Insights and Methods
Adolescent Substance Abuse Treatment: Effective Interventions
Multidimensional Family Therapy and Cognitive-Behavioral Group Treatment
Research indicates that multidimensional family therapy and cognitive-behavioral group treatment are among the most effective interventions for adolescent substance abuse. These treatments have received the highest level of evidentiary support due to their structured frameworks and psycho-social nature, making them appealing to social work practitioners1.
Other Effective Interventions
In addition to the top-rated therapies, seven other interventions have shown evidence of effectiveness. These treatments are also psycho-social in nature and exist within structured frameworks, which are crucial for successful outcomes in adolescent substance abuse treatment1.
Systematic Evaluation and Decision Tree Methods
Comprehensive Characterization and Monitoring
A systematic procedure for evaluating and treating adolescents with known or suspected substance abuse integrates assessment with intervention. This approach allows for a comprehensive characterization of the adolescent's problems and enables quantitative monitoring of treatment progress and outcomes2.
Decision Tree Method
The decision tree method is particularly useful in systematically evaluating and treating adolescent substance abuse. It helps in identifying the most appropriate interventions based on the specific needs and conditions of the adolescent2.
Neuropsychological Assessment in Substance Abuse
Cognitive Functioning and Therapeutic Management
Neuropsychological assessments are valuable for evaluating cognitive functioning in substance abusers, which is crucial for optimal therapeutic management and treatment planning. Chronic abusers of CNS depressants, alcohol, opiates, and possibly cocaine often show neuropsychological impairments, especially when these substances are used in a polydrug pattern3.
Distinguishing Acute and Long-term Deficits
It is essential to distinguish between acute drug effects and long-term stable deficits. Neuropsychological evaluations should consider personal, demographic, and neuromedical background variables that can affect cognitive functioning3.
Behavioral Assessment and Treatment Planning
Evaluation of Substance Use Functions
Effective assessment and treatment planning for substance abuse require a detailed evaluation of the functions of a substance abuser's alcohol and drug use. This evaluation is necessary to develop meaningful and effective treatment goals and strategies4.
Clinical Application of Assessment Methods
Several new and established assessment methods and instruments can be used in clinical practice to evaluate the severity of alcohol and drug problems. The utility of each technique depends on the specific needs and problems of each client4.
Structured Assessment Instruments
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
Efficient and organized assessment of substance use disorders is essential for clinical research, treatment planning, and referral to adjunctive services. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th Edition, Text Revision, provides a framework for formalized assessment5.
Widely Used Instruments
Six widely used structured assessment instruments are discussed to help researchers and clinical programs identify the most suitable tools for their particular situations and purposes5.
Adolescent Substance Abuse Screening
Substance Abuse Subtle Screening Inventory (SASSI-A)
The SASSI-A is used to assess unacknowledged substance abuse among adolescents. However, it has shown a high number of false positives and is significantly affected by ethnicity, limiting its effectiveness in classifying adolescents as chemically dependent6.
Screening for Suspected Substance Abuse
Despite its limitations, the SASSI-A can be moderately effective in screening for suspected substance abuse, particularly among nonadmitting alcohol and drug users6.
Clinical Evaluation Guidelines
Psychosocial Assessment
A general psychosocial assessment of an adolescent's functioning is crucial for evaluating substance abuse. This assessment should cover family relationships, school performance, peer relationships, legal difficulties, leisure activities, and self-perception7.
Enhancing Accurate Disclosure
Strategies to enhance accurate disclosure of substance use include developing rapport with the adolescent, ordering questions strategically, and using an historical perspective to discuss initial and current use patterns7.
Comprehensive Assessment for Identified Substance Abusers
Holistic Evaluation
A complete assessment of identified substance-abusing adolescents must focus on every sphere of the child's life, not just the quantity and frequency of drug use. This includes family evaluation and psychological testing8.
Family Involvement in Treatment
Treatment programs for substance-abusing adolescents should involve the family and aim for abstinence from mood-altering substances as a major component of recovery8.
Impact of Comorbid Psychiatric Diagnoses
Treatment Outcomes
Patients with comorbid psychiatric disorders generally show improvement in substance use and social functioning outcomes after treatment. However, those with major psychiatric disorders fare worse on psychological symptoms and employment outcomes compared to those with only substance use disorders9.
Treatment Orientation
There are no significant differences in outcomes between different treatment orientations, such as 12-Step and cognitive-behavioral programs, for dually diagnosed patients9.
Conclusion
Effective evaluation and treatment of substance abuse require a multifaceted approach that includes structured interventions, comprehensive assessments, and consideration of comorbid conditions. By integrating these methods, practitioners can better address the complex needs of substance abusers and improve treatment outcomes.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic
Adolescent Substance Abuse Treatment: A Synthesis of Controlled Evaluations
Multidimensional family therapy and cognitive-behavioral group treatment are effective for treating adolescent substance abuse, with several other interventions showing evidence of effectiveness.
Meta-Analysis
Highly CitedEvaluation and treatment of adolescent substance abuse: a decision tree method.
The decision tree method effectively evaluates and treats adolescents with substance abuse, providing comprehensive assessment and monitoring of treatment progress and outcomes.
Highly CitedNeuropsychological assessment of substance abusers: review and recommendations.
Neuropsychological assessment of substance abusers can help identify cognitive impairments and help optimize treatment planning.
Highly CitedBehavioral assessment and treatment planning with alcohol and drug abusers: A review with an emphasis on clinical application☆
This paper reviews various assessment methods and instruments for evaluating alcohol and drug problems and providing direction for treatment planning, emphasizing the importance of considering client needs and recent research findings.
Literature ReviewAssessing Addiction: Concepts and Instruments
This paper introduces basic concepts of formalized assessment for substance abuse and addiction, and six widely used structured assessment instruments, to help researchers and clinical programs identify the best fit for their needs.
Rigorous JournalEvaluation of Adolescent Offenders with Substance Abuse
The SASSI-A is not effective in identifying chemically dependent adolescents and has a limited role in screening for suspected substance abuse in adolescent offenders.
Observational StudyInterviewing guidelines for the clinical evaluation of adolescent substance abuse.
Assess adolescent patients' psychosocial functioning to determine if substance abuse is causing behavioral impairment. Obtain accurate substance use history from adolescents. Refer patients to appropriate treatment programs.
The assessment of the identified substance-abusing adolescent.
A comprehensive assessment of the substance-abusing adolescent's life is crucial for selecting the appropriate treatment facility and addressing psychological trauma.
A comparative evaluation of substance abuse treatment IV. The effect of comorbid psychiatric diagnoses on amount of treatment, continuing care, and 1-year outcomes.
Dual diagnosis patients with substance use disorders and comorbid psychiatric disorders show similar substance use and social functioning improvements after treatment, but worse psychological symptoms and employment outcomes.
Observational StudyHighly Cited