Theory of relativity vs newtonian physics
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Fundamental Differences: Theory of Relativity vs Newtonian Physics
The theory of relativity and Newtonian physics are two foundational frameworks in physics, but they differ significantly in their treatment of space, time, and gravity. Newtonian physics, developed in the 17th century, describes space and time as absolute and independent entities, and gravity as a force acting instantaneously at a distance between masses. In contrast, Einstein’s theory of relativity, developed in the early 20th century, unifies space and time into a single four-dimensional spacetime and describes gravity as the curvature of this spacetime caused by mass and energy 37.
Space, Time, and Symmetry: Key Conceptual Shifts
Newtonian physics is based on the concepts of absolute space and time, where events occur in a fixed, unchanging backdrop. The laws of motion and gravity are formulated using these absolute concepts . Special relativity, however, shows that measurements of space and time are relative to the observer’s state of motion, and that the speed of light is constant for all observers. This leads to phenomena such as time dilation and length contraction, which have no counterpart in Newtonian physics .
The transition from Newtonian to relativistic physics can be understood through the language of symmetry. Special relativity is based on Poincaré symmetry, while Newtonian physics is based on Galilean symmetry. The Newtonian theory can be seen as an approximation of relativity when speeds are much less than the speed of light 46.
Gravity: Force vs. Geometry
In Newtonian physics, gravity is a force that acts instantaneously between two masses. This model works well for most everyday situations but fails to explain certain phenomena, such as the precise orbit of Mercury or the behavior of light near massive objects . General relativity replaces the concept of gravitational force with the idea that mass and energy curve spacetime, and objects move along the paths determined by this curvature. This geometric view of gravity has been confirmed by many experiments and observations, such as the bending of light by gravity and the behavior of binary pulsars 35.
Limits and Approximations: When Theories Overlap
For most practical purposes involving low speeds and weak gravitational fields, Newtonian physics provides accurate predictions. In these limits, the equations of general relativity reduce to those of Newtonian gravity, a relationship that can be formalized using mathematical techniques such as symmetry contraction and post-Newtonian approximations 4910. However, in strong gravitational fields or at speeds close to the speed of light, only relativity provides correct predictions 34.
Ongoing Debates and Alternative Theories
Some researchers have proposed alternative versions of relativity that attempt to reconcile or reformulate the foundations of physics using Newtonian concepts or new mathematical frameworks. These alternatives often aim to address perceived gaps or abstractness in both Newtonian and relativistic theories, but they remain outside mainstream physics and are subject to ongoing debate 18.
Conclusion
Newtonian physics and the theory of relativity offer different perspectives on the nature of space, time, and gravity. Newtonian physics is simpler and works well for everyday phenomena, while relativity provides a more accurate and comprehensive framework for understanding the universe, especially at high speeds and in strong gravitational fields. The two theories are connected, with Newtonian physics serving as a limiting case of relativity under certain conditions, but their conceptual foundations are fundamentally different 3467.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic