Whey protein vs other protein sources
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Whey Protein vs Other Protein Sources: Muscle Mass and Strength Gains
Whey protein is widely recognized for its high quality and complete amino acid profile, making it a popular choice for muscle building and recovery. Studies show that whey protein supplementation, either alone or as part of a multi-ingredient formula, leads to small but significant extra gains in lean body mass and strength compared to iso-energetic supplements containing carbohydrates or other non-whey protein sources in resistance-trained individuals. These effects are more pronounced when whey is combined with other ingredients like creatine, especially for upper body strength gains 12.
Amino Acid Profile and Protein Quality: Whey vs Plant and Animal Proteins
Whey protein stands out due to its high leucine content and rapid digestibility, which are key for maximizing muscle protein synthesis (MPS) after exercise. Compared to other protein sources such as soy or casein, whey generally provides a higher proportion of essential amino acids and is more effective at stimulating MPS, especially when total daily protein intake is below 1.6 g/kg body weight 279. However, when daily protein intake is sufficient, the differences between protein sources become less significant .
Whey vs Soy and Plant-Based Protein Blends
Direct comparisons between whey and soy proteins indicate that whey is more effective for rapid muscle building, while soy may be more suitable for fat loss or mass reduction . In animal studies, whey led to greater skeletal muscle anabolism than soy, with soy resulting in lower body weight and lean mass gains . In humans, higher doses of whey protein elicit a greater insulin response than soy, but both proteins have similar effects on glucose homeostasis and satiety at lower doses .
Recent research also shows that plant-based protein blends (such as combinations of pea, rice, and canola) can stimulate post-exercise muscle protein synthesis to the same extent as whey protein in resistance-trained adults, provided the blend is formulated to match the amino acid profile of whey . This suggests that well-designed plant protein blends can be a viable alternative to whey for muscle recovery and growth .
Digestibility and Nutritional Value
Whey protein supplements generally have higher digestibility and protein quality scores compared to soy and caseinate isolates. Both U.S. and Brazilian whey protein supplements scored higher in digestibility and essential amino acid content than plant-based or casein supplements, although some products may not fully meet the increased amino acid requirements of athletes .
Pre-Sleep Protein and Muscle Recovery
When it comes to muscle recovery after damaging exercise, consuming whey or plant-based protein before sleep does not appear to provide additional benefits in middle-aged men who already meet their daily protein needs. Both protein sources performed similarly, with no significant differences in muscle recovery outcomes .
Whey Protein in Special Contexts: Human Milk and Infant Nutrition
Whey proteins are also the most abundant proteins in human milk, playing a crucial role in infant growth, immunity, and development. The composition and function of whey proteins in human milk differ from those in cow’s milk and other sources, highlighting their unique role in early nutrition .
Conclusion
Whey protein is a high-quality, complete protein source that is particularly effective for building muscle mass and strength, especially when combined with resistance training and other ingredients like creatine. While whey generally outperforms single-source plant proteins like soy for muscle anabolism, well-formulated plant protein blends can match whey’s effectiveness in stimulating muscle protein synthesis. For most people, especially those meeting their daily protein requirements, the choice between whey and other protein sources may come down to dietary preferences, digestibility, and specific nutritional needs.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic