Are birds or crocodiles more related to dinosaurs
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Birds and Crocodiles: Their Relationship to Dinosaurs
Evolutionary Lineage of Archosaurs
Birds and crocodiles are the only living representatives of the Archosauria, a group that also includes non-avian dinosaurs and pterosaurs . This shared ancestry places both birds and crocodiles in close evolutionary proximity to dinosaurs. However, the degree of relatedness varies when considering different aspects of their biology and evolutionary history.
Genetic and Morphological Evidence
Genomic studies have provided significant insights into the evolutionary relationships among archosaurs. The genomes of birds and crocodilians have been sequenced and compared, revealing that both groups share a common ancestor with dinosaurs. Despite this shared ancestry, birds exhibit a higher rate of genomic evolution compared to the slow evolutionary rates observed in crocodilians. This rapid evolution in birds is reflected in their diverse morphologies and complex behaviors, which are more derived compared to the relatively conserved traits in crocodiles.
Physiological and Developmental Traits
Physiological similarities between birds and crocodiles include shared amino acids in β-keratins and homologous oviduct structures. Additionally, both groups exhibit similar gene expression patterns in limb development, suggesting a common developmental pathway inherited from their archosaur ancestors. However, brain development patterns differ significantly; birds retain a compact brain shape into adulthood, a trait seen in non-avian dinosaurs, whereas crocodiles' brains elongate as they mature. This indicates that birds may retain more paedomorphic traits from their dinosaur ancestors compared to crocodiles.
Behavioral and Ecological Adaptations
Behavioral studies also highlight differences and similarities between birds and crocodiles. Crocodilians exhibit complex reproductive behaviors, such as nest building and parental care, which may reflect primitive archosaur characteristics, including those of dinosaurs. Birds, on the other hand, have evolved a wide range of behaviors and ecological adaptations, many of which are not seen in crocodiles. This divergence in behavior and ecology further underscores the evolutionary distance between birds and crocodiles despite their common ancestry.
Phylogenetic Relationships
Phylogenetic analyses have consistently placed birds closer to theropod dinosaurs, a group that includes well-known species like Velociraptor and Tyrannosaurus rex . This close relationship is supported by numerous anatomical features, such as the structure of the middle ear and specific cranial characteristics. In contrast, crocodiles are more distantly related to dinosaurs, falling outside the direct lineage that leads to birds.
Conclusion
In summary, while both birds and crocodiles share a common archosaur ancestor with dinosaurs, birds are more closely related to dinosaurs, particularly theropod dinosaurs, than crocodiles. This closer relationship is evident in their rapid genomic evolution, retained paedomorphic traits, and numerous anatomical similarities. Crocodiles, although sharing some primitive archosaur traits with dinosaurs, represent a more basal lineage within the archosaur clade.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic