Does creatine improve cognition? Group together the pro and con cases
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
The Impact of Creatine on Cognitive Function: A Comprehensive Review
Introduction to Creatine and Cognitive Function
Creatine, a popular supplement known for its benefits in enhancing athletic performance, has also been investigated for its potential cognitive benefits. This article synthesizes the findings from various studies to provide a clear understanding of whether creatine supplementation can improve cognitive function.
Pro Case: Evidence Supporting Cognitive Benefits of Creatine
Short-Term Memory and Intelligence
Several studies suggest that creatine supplementation may improve certain aspects of cognitive function, particularly short-term memory and intelligence. A systematic review of randomized controlled trials found evidence that creatine administration could enhance short-term memory and intelligence/reasoning in healthy individuals. This review highlighted that vegetarians might experience more pronounced benefits in memory tasks compared to meat-eaters, although the effects on other cognitive domains were inconsistent.
Cognitive Benefits in Stressful Conditions
Creatine appears to be particularly beneficial in situations where cognitive processes are stressed. Research indicates that creatine supplementation can improve cognitive performance during sleep deprivation, experimental hypoxia, and other cognitively demanding tasks. This suggests that creatine may help maintain cognitive function under conditions of acute stress.
Potential Benefits for Older Adults
Meta-analyses have shown that creatine supplementation can enhance memory performance, especially in older adults. One study found significant improvements in memory measures among older adults (66-76 years) compared to younger individuals (11-31 years). This indicates that creatine may be more effective in populations with greater cognitive demands or deficits.
Neuroprotective Effects
Creatine has also demonstrated neuroprotective properties, potentially reducing neuronal cell loss in experimental models of neurological diseases. It interacts with various receptors and enzymes in the brain, suggesting its role as a neuromodulator. These properties could make creatine beneficial for individuals with neurodegenerative conditions or those recovering from brain injuries .
Con Case: Evidence Against Cognitive Benefits of Creatine
No Significant Improvement in Healthy Young Adults
Despite some positive findings, other studies have reported no significant cognitive benefits from creatine supplementation in healthy young adults. For instance, a study involving 30 participants found that six weeks of creatine supplementation did not improve cognitive performance or change prefrontal cortex activation during cognitive tasks. Similarly, another study using the ImPACT test found no significant changes in cognitive measures between creatine and placebo groups, although females in the creatine group scored higher on visual memory tests.
Conflicting Results Across Cognitive Domains
The effects of creatine on various cognitive domains remain unclear and inconsistent. While some studies report improvements in short-term memory and intelligence, others find no significant changes in long-term memory, spatial memory, attention, executive function, or reaction time . These conflicting results suggest that the cognitive benefits of creatine may be limited to specific conditions or populations.
Lack of Effect in Combined Supplementation
Research examining the combined effects of creatine and other supplements, such as caffeine, has also yielded mixed results. One study found that while the combination of creatine nitrate and caffeine improved cognitive performance compared to creatine alone, neither supplement significantly altered subjective readiness to perform or sleep quality. This indicates that the cognitive benefits of creatine may not be enhanced by co-ingestion with other supplements.
Conclusion
The current body of research presents a mixed picture regarding the cognitive benefits of creatine supplementation. While there is evidence supporting improvements in short-term memory, intelligence, and cognitive performance under stress, other studies report no significant effects in healthy young adults or across various cognitive domains. The potential benefits of creatine may be more pronounced in older adults, vegetarians, and individuals under cognitive stress. However, further research with larger sample sizes and diverse populations is needed to clarify these effects and determine optimal dosing strategies.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic