How do we understand and model the nature of scientific explanation and prediction?
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Understanding and Modeling the Nature of Scientific Explanation and Prediction
Introduction to Scientific Explanation and Prediction
Scientific explanation and prediction are fundamental to the advancement of knowledge. They allow us to understand the natural world and anticipate future events based on current knowledge. The relationship between models, explanations, and predictions is complex and multifaceted, involving both metaphysical and epistemological dimensions2.
Models as Tools for Scientific Explanation
The Role of Models in Explanation
Models play a crucial role in scientific explanation by providing a structured way to represent and understand complex phenomena. They often involve idealizations and abstractions, which, despite their simplifications, can offer genuine scientific explanations under certain conditions4. For instance, Bohr's model of the atom, despite its inaccuracies, provided significant explanatory power in understanding atomic structure4.
Types of Models and Their Explanatory Power
Different types of models serve various explanatory purposes. Phenomenological models describe observable phenomena without necessarily explaining the underlying mechanisms, while explanatory models aim to uncover the causal relationships behind these phenomena. Fictional models, although not entirely accurate, can still provide valuable insights by highlighting specific aspects of the system being studied4.
The Interplay Between Models and Predictions
Prediction as a Measure of Understanding
Prediction is a critical aspect of scientific understanding. It is argued that the ability to make accurate predictions is the ultimate test of a scientific model's validity6. In ecology, for example, the focus on prediction has been suggested as a way to enhance the reproducibility and generalizability of scientific findings6.
The Role of Explainable AI in Prediction
In fields like chemistry, the use of deep learning models for prediction has been met with skepticism due to their "black-box" nature. Explainable AI (XAI) addresses this by providing tools to interpret these models and their predictions, thereby enhancing their reliability and acceptance among scientists5. Techniques such as chemical counterfactuals and descriptor explanations help elucidate the structure-property relationships that underlie predictive models5.
Educational Approaches to Scientific Modeling
Learning Progressions in Scientific Modeling
Educational strategies have been developed to make scientific modeling accessible and meaningful for learners. A learning progression for scientific modeling includes constructing, using, evaluating, and revising models, along with understanding their purpose and nature3. This approach helps students move from simple illustrative models to more sophisticated explanatory models, thereby enhancing their ability to make predictions and understand complex phenomena3.
Conceptual Models in Education
Conceptual models are also used to improve students' understanding of scientific explanations. These models help students recall conceptual information, reduce reliance on rote memorization, and foster creative problem-solving skills7. By engaging with conceptual models, students can develop a deeper understanding of scientific principles and their applications7.
Theoretical Perspectives on Scientific Understanding
Inferential Models of Understanding
Recent research in cognitive psychology suggests that scientific understanding involves making causal and logical inferences based on incoming information. Developing mental models that incorporate these inferences is essential for achieving a scientific understanding of phenomena8. This inferential approach highlights the importance of logical reasoning in constructing scientific explanations8.
Unification and Epistemic Explanation
Scientific understanding also involves unifying disparate observations into a coherent world-picture. Epistemic explanations, which increase the degree of unification of observed events, are crucial for this process. The construction of such explanations relies heavily on the application of scientific theories to observed phenomena10.
Conclusion
Understanding and modeling scientific explanation and prediction involve a complex interplay of models, theories, and educational practices. Models serve as essential tools for both explaining and predicting phenomena, while educational strategies and cognitive theories provide frameworks for developing a deeper understanding of these processes. By integrating these approaches, we can enhance our ability to explain and predict the natural world, thereby advancing scientific knowledge.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic
Models of Human Scientific Discovery
A formal model of human scientific discovery should address core cognitive science problems, including mental models, complex system interactions, and active interrogation through experiments.
How are Models and Explanations Related?
This paper provides a unified framework for analyzing the various relationships between scientific models and scientific explanations, revealing that epistemological relationships are not always dependent on metaphysical relationships.
Developing a learning progression for scientific modeling: Making scientific modeling accessible and meaningful for learners
A learning progression for scientific modeling can make the practice accessible and meaningful for learners, guiding their understanding and development of scientific models as tools for predicting and explaining.
Highly CitedHow scientific models can explain
Scientific models can offer genuine scientific explanations under certain conditions, as demonstrated by Bohr's model of the atom.
Highly CitedA Perspective on Explanations of Molecular Prediction Models
Explainable artificial intelligence (XAI) in chemistry can improve the interpretability of deep learning models and predictions, revealing structure-property relationships in predictions of solubility, blood-brain barrier permeability, and scent of molecules.
The priority of prediction in ecological understanding
A renewed focus on prediction in ecology can advance understanding and progress towards a more general understanding of the natural world.
Highly CitedModels for Understanding
Conceptual models improve students' understanding of scientific explanations, increase creative solutions, and decrease verbatim retention.
Literature ReviewHighly CitedAn Inferential Model of Scientific Understanding
Scientific understanding involves developing mental models that incorporate correct causal and logical properties, rather than just accepting explanations.
Reintroducing Prediction to Explanation
Reintroducing prediction to explanation can enrich theories of explanation and clarify what makes an explanation scientific.
Highly CitedExplaining, understanding and scientific theories
Scientific epistemic explanations can enhance the degree of unification of observed events in our world-picture by applying scientific theories.
Try another search
The safety and environmental impact of space debris on satellite operations and space exploration missions.
Philosophy of Science:
What is the impact of climate change on urban infrastructure?
What are the symptoms of Ebola virus disease?
link between life skill OMS and outdoor activities
What are the symptoms of hypertension (high blood pressure)?