What are the benefits and risks of nuclear energy?
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Benefits and Risks of Nuclear Energy
Economic and Environmental Benefits of Nuclear Energy
Nuclear energy offers significant economic and environmental benefits. Economically, it is a crucial power source for many countries, providing a stable and reliable supply of electricity. For instance, a study comparing nuclear power to conventional alternatives in Helsinki found that a 1000 MW(e) nuclear option was $9.1 million per year more economical than the optimal conventional scenario, while also reducing excess mortality by 2-5 fatal injuries annually. Additionally, nuclear power contributes to global energy security and is promoted as a solution for climate change mitigation due to its low carbon emissions . The reduction in pollutants such as SO2, NOX, and PM10 from substituting coal-fired power with nuclear power results in significant health benefits, as evidenced by avoided disability-adjusted life years (DALYs).
Health and Safety Risks of Nuclear Energy
Despite its benefits, nuclear energy poses substantial health and safety risks. The potential release of harmful radioactive substances during accidents is a major concern. For example, the health risks associated with nuclear power plants include radiation risks during normal operations and severe accident scenarios, which can lead to significant health impacts measured in DALYs. Historical nuclear accidents, such as those at Chernobyl and Fukushima, have highlighted the severe consequences of radiation exposure, including genetic mutations, cancer, and developmental abnormalities. The long-term management of radioactive waste, which remains hazardous for thousands of years, also presents a significant environmental and societal challenge .
Public Perception and Acceptance of Nuclear Energy
Public perception plays a critical role in the acceptance of nuclear energy. Studies have shown that trust in authorities, perceived benefits, and knowledge positively influence public acceptance, while perceived risks and costs negatively impact it. The "Not In My Back Yard" (NIMBY) effect is prevalent, particularly in developing countries, where the public's incomplete understanding of nuclear risks and benefits leads to resistance against nuclear power plant siting. Media coverage of nuclear accidents tends to emphasize the potential threats of ionizing radiation, further shaping public opinion against nuclear energy.
Balancing Benefits and Risks
Balancing the benefits and risks of nuclear energy requires comprehensive risk prevention, control measures, and effective risk communication. Developing precise emergency plans for both normal operations and accident conditions is essential to mitigate risks. Additionally, fostering public understanding through scientific-based risk-benefit assessments can help reduce the NIMBY effect and improve public acceptance .
Conclusion
Nuclear energy presents a complex interplay of significant economic and environmental benefits alongside substantial health and safety risks. While it offers a low-carbon solution for global energy needs and climate change mitigation, the potential for severe accidents and the challenges of radioactive waste management cannot be overlooked. Effective risk management and transparent communication are crucial to harnessing the benefits of nuclear energy while minimizing its risks.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic