Does intergroup contact reduce prejudice?
Searched over 200M research papers
Research Analysis by Consensus
Consensus Meter
The Impact of Intergroup Contact on Reducing Prejudice
Introduction to Intergroup Contact Theory
Intergroup contact theory posits that direct interaction between members of different groups can reduce prejudice and improve intergroup relations. This theory has been extensively studied and validated across various contexts and populations.
Efficacy of Intergroup Contact in Reducing Prejudice
General Findings
A comprehensive meta-analysis of 515 studies involving over 250,000 subjects confirms that intergroup contact typically reduces prejudice (mean r = -0.21). This reduction in prejudice is observed across different types of outgroups, including racial, ethnic, and other social categories . The findings are consistent across various settings and populations, indicating the robustness of intergroup contact as a tool for prejudice reduction.
Mechanisms of Prejudice Reduction
Intergroup contact reduces prejudice through several key mechanisms. These include enhancing knowledge about the outgroup, reducing anxiety about intergroup interactions, and increasing empathy and perspective-taking . Among these, reducing anxiety and increasing empathy are particularly strong mediators of the contact-prejudice relationship .
Moderating Factors
The effectiveness of intergroup contact can be influenced by perceived intergroup threat and discrimination. Interestingly, contact's beneficial effects are strong even among individuals who perceive high levels of threat or discrimination. This suggests that intergroup contact can be effective in challenging environments where prejudice is deeply rooted.
Specific Contexts and Conditions
Online Intergroup Contact
With the advent of digital communication, online intergroup contact has also been shown to reduce prejudice effectively. A meta-analysis of 23 studies found that online interactions can significantly improve intergroup relations, especially when the contact involves cooperation. This indicates that the principles of intergroup contact theory extend to virtual environments as well.
Direct and Indirect Contact
Both direct (face-to-face) and indirect (extended or virtual) contact interventions are effective in reducing ethnic prejudice. These interventions not only improve attitudes toward individuals involved in the contact but also generalize to the entire outgroup. This effect persists over time, demonstrating the long-term benefits of intergroup contact.
Cultural and Social Contexts
The impact of intergroup contact varies across cultural contexts. In more egalitarian cultures, the association between contact and reduced prejudice is stronger compared to more hierarchical cultures. This suggests that societal values and norms play a significant role in moderating the effectiveness of intergroup contact.
Challenges and Criticisms
Minority vs. Majority Groups
The relationship between intergroup contact and prejudice reduction tends to be weaker among minority groups compared to majority groups. Additionally, the optimal conditions for intergroup contact, such as equal status and common goals, are more predictive of prejudice reduction among majority groups.
Ironic Effects
There is evidence suggesting that intergroup contact may have the "ironic" effect of reducing support for social change among disadvantaged groups. This is because positive intergroup interactions can lead to a perception of reduced injustice and a decrease in collective action. However, these effects are small and variable, indicating the need for further research to fully understand these dynamics.
Conclusion
Intergroup contact is a powerful tool for reducing prejudice and improving intergroup relations. Its effectiveness is mediated by increased empathy and reduced anxiety, and it is robust across various contexts, including online environments. While there are challenges and nuances, such as varying effects among minority and majority groups and potential ironic effects, the overall evidence supports the positive impact of intergroup contact on fostering more tolerant societies.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic