Is Milk thistle safe?
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Safety of Milk Thistle (Silybum marianum): A Comprehensive Review
Introduction to Milk Thistle Safety
Milk thistle (Silybum marianum) is a widely used herbal supplement, primarily known for its hepatoprotective properties. It is commonly used to treat liver and biliary disorders, and its active component, silymarin, is a mixture of flavonoid complexes that protect liver and kidney cells from toxic effects. This article synthesizes the findings from multiple studies to evaluate the safety profile of milk thistle.
Clinical Trials and Safety Assessments
General Safety in Human Use
Several clinical trials have assessed the safety of milk thistle in humans. These studies consistently report that milk thistle is generally safe and well-tolerated. Adverse effects are rare and usually mild, including gastrointestinal upset and mild laxative effects . One study even noted that silymarin, the active component, is safe at high doses of up to 700 mg three times a day for 24 weeks, with only minor gastrointestinal discomforts such as nausea and diarrhea.
Safety in Specific Populations
Milk thistle has also been evaluated for safety in specific populations, including pregnant women and patients with chronic liver disease. One clinical trial indicated that silymarin is safe during pregnancy, with no anomalies reported, although caution is advised, and more studies are needed. For patients with chronic liver disease, milk thistle was found to be safe, with adverse effects indistinguishable from placebo in clinical trials.
Safety in Animal Studies
Animal studies have further supported the safety of milk thistle. It has been used in various animals, including farm animals, dogs, cats, and horses, with positive effects on liver function and overall health. No significant adverse effects were reported in these studies, suggesting that milk thistle is safe for use in animals as well .
Concerns and Quality Control Issues
Variability in Commercial Preparations
Despite the general consensus on the safety of milk thistle, concerns have been raised about the quality and consistency of commercial milk thistle supplements. Studies have found significant variability in the silymarin content of different products, which can affect their efficacy and safety. Some preparations were found to contain toxic contaminants, such as mycotoxins and pesticides, raising serious health concerns . This highlights the need for strict quality control measures to ensure the safety of milk thistle supplements.
Potential for Contamination
The presence of contaminants in commercial milk thistle products is a significant safety issue. High concentrations of mycotoxins, pesticides, and microbiological contamination have been detected in some products, which could pose health risks to consumers. Therefore, it is crucial to ensure that milk thistle supplements are sourced from reputable manufacturers and undergo rigorous testing for contaminants.
Conclusion
Overall, milk thistle is considered safe and well-tolerated when used within the recommended dose range. Clinical trials and animal studies support its safety profile, with only minor and rare adverse effects reported. However, the variability in the quality of commercial preparations and the potential for contamination underscore the importance of stringent quality control measures. Consumers should be cautious and choose products from reputable sources to ensure safety. Further high-quality clinical trials are needed to confirm the long-term safety and efficacy of milk thistle.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic