What are the effects of different types of stretching on flexibility and muscle health?
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Effects of Different Types of Stretching on Flexibility and Muscle Health
Static Stretching: Enhancing Flexibility with Potential Strength Trade-offs
Static stretching (SS) involves holding a stretch for a prolonged period, typically around 30 seconds. Research indicates that SS significantly increases range of motion (ROM) and flexibility. For instance, a study comparing static stretching with dynamic range of motion (DROM) training found that a 30-second static stretch was more effective in enhancing hamstring flexibility than DROM. Additionally, SS has been shown to decrease passive stiffness and increase passive torque, contributing to improved flexibility .
However, SS can also lead to a temporary decrease in muscle strength. Studies have reported reductions in maximal voluntary strength and muscle power immediately after static stretching . This suggests that while SS is beneficial for increasing flexibility, it may not be ideal immediately before activities requiring maximal strength or power.
Dynamic Stretching: Balancing Flexibility and Performance
Dynamic stretching (DS) involves moving parts of the body through a full range of motion in a controlled manner. DS has been found to increase flexibility and ROM effectively. It also tends to have a positive impact on subsequent muscular performance, such as force, power, sprint, and jump capabilities. The improvements in performance are attributed to reduced muscle-tendon stiffness and increased muscle temperature, which enhance muscle contraction efficiency.
Unlike static stretching, DS does not significantly decrease muscle strength. In fact, it can maintain or even improve muscle performance, making it a suitable option for warm-ups before activities that require strength and power .
Combined Stretching: Integrating Static and Dynamic Techniques
Combined stretching (CS), which incorporates both static and dynamic stretching, has been explored for its potential benefits. Research shows that CS can increase ROM and passive torque while also decreasing passive stiffness, similar to SS and DS individually. However, CS may lead to a decrease in concentric muscle force, similar to SS, but not as pronounced as when only static stretching is performed.
Passive vs. Active Warm-Up: Effects on Flexibility and Muscle Function
Warm-up routines, whether passive (e.g., sitting in a warm room) or active (e.g., cycling, submaximal contractions), are crucial for preparing muscles for stretching. Both passive and active warm-ups have been found to similarly improve neuromuscular function and flexibility. However, active warm-ups are often perceived as more effective for subsequent muscle performance, while neurodynamic stretching (a form of active stretching) is considered most efficient for enhancing flexibility.
Stretching Duration: Longer Durations Yield Greater Flexibility Gains
The duration of stretching plays a significant role in flexibility improvements. Studies indicate that longer stretching durations lead to greater increases in flexibility. For example, stretching for 60 minutes per day resulted in higher flexibility gains compared to shorter durations of 10 or 30 minutes. This suggests that for substantial flexibility improvements, longer stretching sessions may be more beneficial.
Conclusion
Different types of stretching—static, dynamic, and combined—offer unique benefits for flexibility and muscle health. Static stretching is highly effective for increasing flexibility but may temporarily reduce muscle strength. Dynamic stretching enhances flexibility while maintaining or improving muscle performance, making it ideal for pre-activity warm-ups. Combined stretching integrates the benefits of both static and dynamic techniques but may still affect muscle strength. Additionally, both passive and active warm-ups can effectively prepare muscles for stretching, with active warm-ups being more favorable for muscle performance. Finally, longer stretching durations are more effective for significant flexibility gains. Understanding these nuances can help individuals and athletes optimize their stretching routines for better flexibility and muscle health.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic