Check out this answer from Consensus:
The question of whether fish feel pain is complex and multifaceted. While there is substantial evidence suggesting that fish have the capacity for pain perception, there are also valid arguments against this view. Regardless of the exact nature of pain in fish, the ethical implications of our interactions with them cannot be ignored. Further research is needed to fully understand the mechanisms of pain in fish and to develop guidelines that ensure their welfare.
The question of whether fish feel pain has been a subject of intense debate among scientists, ethicists, and the general public. Understanding pain in fish is not only crucial for animal welfare considerations but also for informing fishing practices and legislation. This article explores the current scientific evidence on fish pain, examining both sides of the argument.
What is Pain?
Pain is a complex experience that involves both sensory and emotional components. The sensory aspect, known as nociception, is the detection of harmful stimuli, while the emotional aspect involves the perception of discomfort or suffering. In mammals, pain is typically associated with specific brain regions and neural pathways.
Evidence Supporting Fish Pain
Several studies suggest that fish possess nociceptors, the sensory receptors responsible for detecting harmful stimuli, similar to those found in mammals. These nociceptors include both A-delta and C-fibers, although C-fibers are less prevalent in fish compared to mammals1 5 7.
Behavioral studies have shown that fish exhibit changes in behavior and physiology when exposed to potentially painful stimuli. For instance, fish injected with acetic acid or bee venom display increased gill-beat rates and altered swimming patterns, which are mitigated by painkillers like morphine5 7. These findings suggest that fish not only detect harmful stimuli but also experience a form of discomfort that affects their behavior2 3 8.
Moreover, fish have been observed to avoid areas where they previously experienced pain, indicating a memory of the painful event and a motivation to avoid it in the future3 8. This behavioral evidence aligns with the criteria used to define pain in other animals, making a compelling case for the presence of pain in fish.
Arguments Against Fish Pain
Despite the evidence supporting fish pain, some researchers argue that fish lack the necessary neuroanatomical structures to experience pain as humans do. Key points out that fish do not possess the specialized cortical regions associated with the emotional aspects of pain in humans6 10. According to this view, the behavioral responses observed in fish could be purely reflexive, without any conscious experience of pain1 6.
Critics also highlight methodological issues in studies claiming fish feel pain, such as the difficulty in distinguishing between nociception and conscious pain. They argue that many of these studies have not been replicable and that the results have often been misinterpreted1 6.
The Middle Ground
Some researchers propose a middle ground, suggesting that while fish may not experience pain in the same way humans do, they still have a form of pain perception that warrants ethical consideration. For example, the presence of nociceptors and the observed behavioral changes indicate that fish have a functional system for detecting and responding to harmful stimuli, even if the emotional experience of pain is different from that in humans4 9.
Implications for Fish Welfare
If we accept that fish can experience pain, it has significant implications for how we treat them. Practices in commercial fishing, aquaculture, and recreational fishing may need to be re-evaluated to minimize pain and suffering in fish. This could involve changes in handling methods, the use of anesthetics during procedures, and the development of more humane fishing techniques7 8 9.
Do fish feel pain?
Douglas Fenner has answered Near Certain
An expert from National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration in Marine Biology
Yes, they do. Fish are surprisingly intelligent, and they can easily be trained with food rewards. I’ve done that myself. There is evidence that all vertebrates experience pain and can learn to avoid it or escape it. That’s hard to arrange experimentally with fish. There is a review article on this subject, which reviews the published literature and cites that litearature. It is:
Brown, C. 2015. Fish intelligence, sentience, and ethics. Animal Cognition 18: 1-17.