Does Planting Trees Help Reduce Climate Change?

Check out this answer from Consensus:

While tree planting has significant potential to mitigate climate change, it is not a panacea. Effective tree planting initiatives require careful planning, management, and integration with other climate actions. By addressing these challenges, tree planting can be a valuable component of global efforts to combat climate change.

The role of tree planting in mitigating climate change has garnered significant attention in recent years. Various studies have explored the potential benefits and limitations of this approach. This article aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the current understanding of tree planting as a strategy to combat climate change, drawing on insights from multiple research papers.

The Potential of Tree Planting

Planting trees has been identified as a highly effective method for reducing carbon pollution. According to an interview with Professor Tom Crowther, reforestation on a large scale could bring carbon pollution down to levels not seen in a century1. This suggests that tree planting could play a crucial role in global efforts to mitigate climate change.

Challenges and Considerations

However, tree planting is not a simple solution. It must be carefully planned and implemented to achieve the desired outcomes. Poorly planned tree planting initiatives can overshadow other critical actions, such as reducing deforestation and greenhouse gas emissions2. Additionally, the potential for urban trees to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution is limited due to space constraints and the current magnitude of emissions4.

Carbon Sequestration Capacity

In the United States, forests and harvested wood products currently uptake the equivalent of more than 14% of economy-wide CO2 emissions annually. There is potential to increase this capacity by approximately 20% through better forest management and tree planting on understocked productive forestland3. This highlights the significant role that well-managed forests can play in carbon sequestration.

Adaptation and Resilience

Tree planting can also contribute to climate change adaptation by increasing the resilience of forest ecosystems. Diversifying forests by planting tree species more suited to future climate conditions can enhance carbon stocks, net primary productivity, and species diversity5. This approach can help mitigate some of the negative effects of climate change on forest ecosystems.

Urban Tree Planting

Urban tree planting programs have been implemented in many of the world’s major cities to address local environmental and social issues. These programs have documented benefits, such as local cooling, stormwater absorption, and health improvements for residents4. A multidisciplinary framework for urban tree planting in Houston, Texas, has shown promise in improving health, reducing urban heat, and mitigating air pollution through strategic planting of native tree species6.

Economic Considerations

Economic models, such as Nordhaus’ DICE model, have been used to assess the impact of large-scale tree planting on future temperatures. While optimistic scenarios suggest that reforestation could reduce projected future temperatures by more than 30%, the benefits may be limited if industrial emissions increase as a result7. This underscores the need for immediate and sustained action to maximize the benefits of tree planting.

Criticisms and Limitations

Some researchers have criticized overly optimistic estimates of the global tree restoration potential. For example, Bastin et al.’s estimate that tree planting could sequester 205 gigatonnes of carbon has been challenged as being significantly inflated8. This highlights the importance of realistic and evidence-based assessments of tree planting initiatives.

 

---

Does planting trees help reduce climate change?

Lars Hein has answered Uncertain

An expert from Wageningen University and Research Centre in Environmental Science

It depends upon the preceding land use. If planted trees replace forests stands with higher biomass: no. If trees are planted on degraded or previously agricultural land: yes. Note however that carbon is only captured during the growth of the trees. As tree stands become mature, the rate of carbon sequestration decreases. 

 

Does planting trees help reduce climate change?

Bill Laurance has answered Near Certain

An expert from James Cook University in Conservation Science, Ecology

Absolutely. Trees store lots of carbon, thereby slowing climate change, and they emit large amounts of water vapor into the atmosphere, which cools the land via evaporation. 

 

Does planting trees help reduce climate change?

David Lindenmayer has answered Likely

An expert from Australian National University in Conservation Science, Ecology

Yes – it helps store carbon – but ist also critial to leave natural forests intact

 

Does planting trees help reduce climate change?

John D. Bailey has answered Likely

An expert from Oregon State University in Forestry Sciences

At a base level, the answer would always be “yes” – climate change is closely tied to the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, and trees remove carbon dioxide from the air as they photosynthesis and grow. As long-lived woody vegetation, trees are pretty good at storing that carbon for extended time periods (centuries and millennia) both above- and belowground. Also, forests cover vast areas of planet and can therefore extract a lot of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. We have tracked the concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere for a long time, and everyone can see its predictable annual/seasonal fluctuation, which is largely due to trees/forests in the northern hemisphere. None of that can be denied, and all the modeling work I’ve seen on climate have trees/forests as an important variable in the carbon cycle and future projections of climate change. That said, it is only part of the carbon cycle and there are other greenhouse gases, so there are other things to do beyond planting trees and conserving forests. And, there is a finite amount of carbon that can be stored out in our forests anyway. Forests accumulate biomass/carbon as they grow – slowly at first when young, then rapidly during middle age with maximal height and diameter growth depending on the quality of the soil and the amount of sunshine and water available, then slowing down again as they get really old until the reach a relatively steady level of carbon (a balance between removing carbon via photosynthesis and respiration/decomposition). Insects, diseases and abiotic disturbances, including fire, also limit the amount of biomass that can be stored in forests, and they all interact with climate change to lower the maximum amount of carbon storage. The recent increase in large and intense wildfire fundamentally affects the carbon storage trajectory of forests; only a little of the carbon leaves during the wildfire (associated with all the leaves and little branches and stuff on the ground that burns), but abundant standing and down dead trees are on a really different pathway (they emit carbon for decades to centuries) relative to a forest with surviving trees (that continues to remove carbon). That is why we have to worry about unnatural amounts and intensities of wildfires from the carbon and climate perspective.

 

Does planting trees help reduce climate change?

J. Rodrigo Garcia del Campo has answered Likely

An expert from Centro Nacional de Biotecnologia in Ecology

In general, yes. Trees use the carbon dioxide (the main greenhouse gas that helps accelerate climate change) that they get from the atmosphere to grow. They retain it and maintain it as long as they are alive. Through the process of photosynthesis, they take up atmospheric CO2 and emit oxygen (although in lesser quantities than pasture areas). But you have to take into account, above all, the region in which they are planted. Ironically, planting trees in an area where previously there was grass or was covered with snow, could locally increase the temperature because the trees are darker, and this affects the albedo (the amount of reflected solar radiation), they absorb more solar energy and the temperature could rise slightly in the area. The tropics are the optimal areas for planting trees, because there trees grow fastest and thus trap the most CO2. It is also important to remember that planting trees as a compensatory measure is not an authorization to continue polluting: if the use of fossil fuels is not reduced and deforestation is limited, climate change will not reverse.

 

Does planting trees help reduce climate change?

Mark Huxham has answered Uncertain

An expert from Napier University in Environmental Science

The short answer is: ‘it depends’. Trees are crucial to the global carbon balance; they absorb up to 3.1 billion tons of the carbon emitted by humans every year (this is around 27% of all our emissions) and so without the world’s forests climate change would be even more serious than it is at the moment. This means that preserving our natural forests is an essential climate goal. Because we have lost large areas of forest in the last century (for example, around 50% of all mangrove forests) planting more trees seems to be a sensible response to climate change; this should help restore some of the damage done to nature through deforestation as well as increasing the size of the natural carbon sink. However we need to be careful about where we plant and what species we use. There are terrible examples of, for example, planting exotic pine species on peat bogs in the Scottish Highlands; this tends to reduce biodiversity and actually release carbon, since it leads to the drying out of the peat. So yes we should plant more trees, but we should take care to choose the right places and the right species. And our first priority must be to stop all destruction of our existing natural forests.

 

Does planting trees help reduce climate change?

Camille Stevens-Rumann has answered Likely

An expert from Colorado State University in Forestry Sciences

Planting trees increases the potential carbon uptake and thus can help off set our carbon emissions.

 

Does planting trees help reduce climate change?

Alexander Lees has answered Likely

An expert from Manchester Metropolitan University in Conservation Science

Yes – so long as it happens in appropriate places and involves the right species – for example if tree are planted on peat bogs they may increase net carbon emissions a perverse impact of tree planting.

 

Does planting trees help reduce climate change?

Paul Hessburg has answered Uncertain

An expert from United States Forest Service in Forestry Sciences

It depends on where you are geographically, the management and disturbance history that has occurred there, what trees are planted, the stocking levels that are planted (how many trees per unit area), and how the trees are planted (evenly or unevenly spaced, clumped and gapped tree spacing) and how tree stocking is maintained (regular thinning is applied versus only natural thinning). One size does not fit all.

There are more than 60,000 different tree species worldwide, and each has its own unique circumstances for establishment, growth, and development. Similarly, climate change is affecting each of these species in somewhat unique ways.

Some current proposals for widespread tree planting in western North America (wNA) have the potential to make the current wildfire problem worse. Modern wildfires in many wNA forests are driven by a rapidly warming climate, increasing lightning and human ignitions, expanded forest area, density, layering, and woody fuels, and loss of meadows, shrublands, and sparse woodlands due to forest encroachment in the absence of fire. In these locations, planting more trees is a poor fit to the changing conditions. Here, less is likely more.

Where forests have been lost to wildfires and they will still grow under locally changing climatic conditions, replanting trees make sense, and planting densities and species can be matched to the expected climate, wildfire regimes, and changing productivity of the land.

In areas where forest land was cleared for agriculture or other uses and later abandoned, re-establishing forests by tree planting also makes sense. These are a few of many possible examples where the answer will vary.

 

Does planting trees help reduce climate change?

Alexander Koch has answered Likely

An expert from University of Hong Kong in Earth Sciences

Generally yes, but it depends where those trees are being planted and how well they are protected.

Trees can take up more atmospheric CO2 than, for example, grasses, so planting trees on deforested areas, called reforestation, is a way to reduce CO2 levels in the atmosphere and thereby help reducing climate change. Forests also play an important part in the regional hydrological cycle as their canopies release moisture (evapotranspiration) which reduces local temperatures. 

The location where reforestation is happening is important for its overall impact on reducing climate change, because forests also slightly darken the surface compared to grassland which leads to a warming of the surface (called albedo effect). So in regions where the cooling from evapotranspiration is less than the warming from albedo forests can lead to a regional warming. This warming effect then reduces the cooling effect from less CO2 in the atmosphere. Generally the tropics are a good place for reforestation, as trees there can store the highest amounts of carbon and evaporative cooling is stronger than albedo warming, so forests there actually cool the land. In the higher latitudes forests still take up much more CO2 than grass- or farmland but a stronger albedo warming counteracts the CO2 cooling.

Generally reforestation is preferable over afforestation where historically tree-less or tree-sparse ecosystems like savannahs are converted to forests as these regions are often more fire-prone and have evolved to support a distinct flora and fauna.

CO2 needs to be stored away from the atmosphere for multiple decades to centuries, this means trees need to live sufficiently long to help reducing climate change in the long-term. Fires, insect outbreaks, disease, climate change, and of course logging are the main risks to this. Some of these risks are easier to control than others, so placing too much hope in planting trees without reducing climate change through other means is a fraught solution to climate change.