Check out this answer from Consensus:
A Charley horse is a muscle cramp or spasm that can cause significant discomfort. While its exact origin remains somewhat mysterious, it is clear that the term has deep roots in American sports culture, particularly baseball. Over time, it has also been adopted in other contexts to describe sudden and challenging situations.
By understanding the historical and etymological background of the term, we can appreciate its place in both language and culture. Further research may one day uncover the definitive origin of this intriguing term.
A Charley horse is a term commonly used to describe a sudden, involuntary muscle spasm or cramp, typically occurring in the leg. This condition is often associated with athletes but can affect anyone. The origin of the term “Charley horse” has been a subject of curiosity and investigation over the years.
Historical Context and Etymology
The term “Charley horse” has been part of the common speech in the United States, particularly in the context of sports. It is believed to have originated from baseball terminology. According to research, the term was included in a list of baseball terms that had become widely recognized and used in everyday language2.
Proposed Origins
Several theories have been proposed regarding the origin of the term “Charley horse.” One notable explanation comes from the world of baseball. Athletes often refer to a Charley horse as a sprain or cramp in a leg muscle, although it can also occur in the arm. For instance, the famous baseball player Babe Ruth once mentioned getting a Charley horse in his arm due to the overwhelming number of admirers he encountered during a tour in Japan1.
Misconceptions and Clarifications
Despite various proposed explanations, many of them have been found unsatisfactory upon closer examination. The search for the true origin of the term has been extensive, and while some clues have been found, a definitive answer remains elusive1.
Modern Usage
In contemporary times, the term “Charley horse” is not only used in sports but has also found its way into other contexts. For example, it has been metaphorically used to describe challenges or setbacks in different fields, such as weather forecasting. In one instance, the remnants of Hurricane Charley led to heavy rain and flooding, which was referred to as giving forecasters a “Charley horse” due to the unexpected and challenging nature of the event3.