Resources

What to Trust and What to Check

Six habits experienced researchers use to check AI-assisted research, with the Consensus features that support each one and a checklist to use with students.

Leila Elamine

Content & Faculty Advisory Board Lead, Consensus

About this guide

Experienced researchers check their sources. They read past the abstract, look at the methods, and make sure a paper says what someone claims it says. Those habits matter just as much when the starting point is an AI research tool.

In conversations with more than 120 faculty members, researchers and academic librarians, six verification habits came up again and again. This guide describes each one in researchers’ own words, shows the Consensus features that support it, and gives one concrete thing to do.

The six habits

  1. Go to the original paper

  2. Check where a statement comes from in the paper

  3. Look at study design, population and sample size

  4. Read the Consensus Meter closely, and read the papers that disagree

  5. Check whether a paper was analyzed in full text

  6. Use the right databases for your field

The guide ends with a checklist for evaluating a Consensus result. Use it in your own research, in peer review or to teach students how to check AI-assisted research.

For more on how faculty fold these habits into their work, see How Faculty Use Consensus.

Download at the top of this page to get the PDF and an editable Word version. Both are designed to meet accessibility standards.

CREATED BY

Leila Elamine

Content & Faculty Advisory Board Lead, Consensus

More resources

5 Ways to Research More Effectively with Consensus

Five practical ways graduate students use Consensus, from getting oriented in a new field to checking a draft before they submit it.

5-ways-to-research-more-effectively-with-consensus

Does the Wording Matter? Practice Exercise

Students ask the same research question five ways, in Consensus and in a general AI chatbot, and compare what changes in the answers.

does-wording-matter-practice-exercise

Starting a Literature Review Practice Exercise

Students build a starting set of five papers in a new research area, then work through one paper in depth with a Consensus Thread beside it.

starting-a-literature-review-practice-exercise

Bring it to your class.

Our team will walk your students through Consensus, live.

Bring it to your class.

Our team will walk your students through Consensus, live.

Bring it to your class.

Our team will walk your students through Consensus, live.