New whitepaper · AI and the academic library
Stewards Again: How Academic Librarians are Leading on AI
What 200 conversations with academic institutions taught us about AI readiness on campus
New whitepaper · AI and the academic library
Stewards Again: How Academic Librarians are Leading on AI
What 200 conversations with academic institutions taught us about AI readiness on campus
New whitepaper · AI and the academic library
Stewards Again: How Academic Librarians are Leading on AI
What 200 conversations with academic institutions taught us about AI readiness on campus













Get the full whitepaper.
The research, the principles, and the playbook from 200+ conversations — sent straight to your inbox.
Five library case studies: SMU, Rice, Basel, Laval, UVA
Five classroom assignments you can run next semester
Six questions to ask of any AI tool before you recommend it
A rough playbook for your library’s first year
Where should we send it?
Please use your work or institution email. We’ll send the PDF and occasional research insights — unsubscribe anytime.
Get the full whitepaper.
The research, the principles, and the playbook from 200+ conversations — sent straight to your inbox.
Five library case studies: SMU, Rice, Basel, Laval, UVA
Five classroom assignments you can run next semester
Six questions to ask of any AI tool before you recommend it
A rough playbook for your library’s first year
Where should we send it?
Please use your work or institution email. We’ll send the PDF and occasional research insights — unsubscribe anytime.
Get the full whitepaper.
The research, the principles, and the playbook from 200+ conversations — sent straight to your inbox.
Five library case studies: SMU, Rice, Basel, Laval, UVA
Five classroom assignments you can run next semester
Six questions to ask of any AI tool before you recommend it
A rough playbook for your library’s first year
Where should we send it?
Please use your work or institution email. We’ll send the PDF and occasional research insights — unsubscribe anytime.
Students and researchers already use AI for academic work at near-universal rates.
Most institutions haven’t caught up.
Nearly half of the world’s top universities give students no guidance on AI at all, and only 5% of students say they fully understand their own institution’s rules.
Students and researchers already use AI for academic work at near-universal rates.
Most institutions haven’t caught up.
Nearly half of the world’s top universities give students no guidance on AI at all, and only 5% of students say they fully understand their own institution’s rules.
Students and researchers already use AI for academic work at near-universal rates.
Most institutions haven’t caught up.
Nearly half of the world’s top universities give students no guidance on AI at all, and only 5% of students say they fully understand their own institution’s rules.
70%+
of students use AI for academic work (Ravšelj et al., 2025)
41%
of US undergrads use it in ways their instructors banned (Stone, 2024)
47%
of top universities give students no AI guidance (Parker et al., 2025)
11–57%
of chatbot citations are fabricated (Naser, 2026)
70%+
of students use AI for academic work (Ravšelj et al., 2025)
41%
of US undergrads use it in ways their instructors banned (Stone, 2024)
47%
of top universities give students no AI guidance (Parker et al., 2025)
11–57%
of chatbot citations are fabricated (Naser, 2026)
70%+
of students use AI for academic work (Ravšelj et al., 2025)
41%
of US undergrads use it in ways their instructors banned (Stone, 2024)
47%
of top universities give students no AI guidance (Parker et al., 2025)
11–57%
of chatbot citations are fabricated (Naser, 2026)
What 200 conversations taught us.
A preview of the paper’s three findings. The full paper adds the evidence, five classroom assignments, five library case studies, and a plan for the first year.
What 200 conversations taught us.
A preview of the paper’s three findings. The full paper adds the evidence, five classroom assignments, five library case studies, and a plan for the first year.
What 200 conversations taught us.
A preview of the paper’s three findings. The full paper adds the evidence, five classroom assignments, five library case studies, and a plan for the first year.
01
Bans and silence both fail.
A ban can’t reach a tool that’s open in every browser tab, and it pushes use out of sight where nobody can correct it. Silence leaves students guessing where the line is, and the tools end up chosen by whatever is free and closest.
WHY BANS AND SILENCE FAIL
Use AI for academic work
70%+
Use it in ways instructors banned
41%
Fully understand the school’s AI rules
5%
Sources: Ravšelj et al. 2025 (n=23,218); Stone 2024, US undergraduates; Digital Education Council 2024
02
Most people are in the middle.
The loudest voices are at the extremes, but most faculty haven’t made up their minds. They’re looking for someone they trust to show them what good practice looks like, and students are asking for the same thing.
WHERE FACULTY ACTUALLY SIT
Skeptics
refusal, fear, cost
The undecided middle
using AI a little, waiting for guidance
Explorers
early adopters
A segmentation study of university teachers found the largest group was neither enthusiastic nor opposed, but undecided on AI, flanked by skeptics on one side and explorers on the other. Proportions illustrative. (Chamorro-Mera & Miranda-Gonzalez, 2025)
03
Librarians are already doing the work, case by case.
They’re catching fake citations, vetting tools, and running workshops, mostly on goodwill and usually without a top-down library position behind them. Five libraries that moved first show what happens next.
FIVE LIBRARIES THAT MOVED FIRST


01
Bans and silence both fail.
A ban can’t reach a tool that’s open in every browser tab, and it pushes use out of sight where nobody can correct it. Silence leaves students guessing where the line is, and the tools end up chosen by whatever is free and closest.
WHY BANS AND SILENCE FAIL
Use AI for academic work
70%+
Use it in ways instructors banned
41%
Fully understand the school’s AI rules
5%
Sources: Ravšelj et al. 2025 (n=23,218); Stone 2024, US undergraduates; Digital Education Council 2024
02
Most people are in the middle.
The loudest voices are at the extremes, but most faculty haven’t made up their minds. They’re looking for someone they trust to show them what good practice looks like, and students are asking for the same thing.
WHERE FACULTY ACTUALLY SIT
Skeptics
refusal, fear, cost
The undecided middle
using AI a little, waiting for guidance
Explorers
early adopters
A segmentation study of university teachers found the largest group was neither enthusiastic nor opposed, but undecided on AI, flanked by skeptics on one side and explorers on the other. Proportions illustrative. (Chamorro-Mera & Miranda-Gonzalez, 2025)
03
Librarians are already doing the work, case by case.
They’re catching fake citations, vetting tools, and running workshops, mostly on goodwill and usually without a top-down library position behind them. Five libraries that moved first show what happens next.
FIVE LIBRARIES THAT MOVED FIRST


01
Bans and silence both fail.
A ban can’t reach a tool that’s open in every browser tab, and it pushes use out of sight where nobody can correct it. Silence leaves students guessing where the line is, and the tools end up chosen by whatever is free and closest.
WHY BANS AND SILENCE FAIL
Use AI for academic work
70%+
Use it in ways instructors banned
41%
Fully understand the school’s AI rules
5%
Sources: Ravšelj et al. 2025 (n=23,218); Stone 2024, US undergraduates; Digital Education Council 2024
02
Most people are in the middle.
The loudest voices are at the extremes, but most faculty haven’t made up their minds. They’re looking for someone they trust to show them what good practice looks like, and students are asking for the same thing.
WHERE FACULTY ACTUALLY SIT
Skeptics
refusal, fear, cost
The undecided middle
using AI a little, waiting for guidance
Explorers
early adopters
A segmentation study of university teachers found the largest group was neither enthusiastic nor opposed, but undecided on AI, flanked by skeptics on one side and explorers on the other. Proportions illustrative. (Chamorro-Mera & Miranda-Gonzalez, 2025)
03
Librarians are already doing the work, case by case.
They’re catching fake citations, vetting tools, and running workshops, mostly on goodwill and usually without a top-down library position behind them. Five libraries that moved first show what happens next.
FIVE LIBRARIES THAT MOVED FIRST


“Information literacy has been kind of our bread and butter for decades in libraries… Our goal is to train students who can think for themselves.”

Chris Chan
University Librarian, Hong Kong Baptist University
“We can get to bigger fish to fry. We can get to the evaluation, the relevancy, the thinking about your topic, the how to think about information.”

Megan Heuer
Director of Educational Initiatives, SMU Libraries
“This allowed a lot of people to make the difference between salesmanship and actual grounded results.”
Yannick Städler
Topic Librarian, University of Basel
“Information literacy has been kind of our bread and butter for decades in libraries… Our goal is to train students who can think for themselves.”

Chris Chan
University Librarian, Hong Kong Baptist University
“We can get to bigger fish to fry. We can get to the evaluation, the relevancy, the thinking about your topic, the how to think about information.”

Megan Heuer
Director of Educational Initiatives, SMU Libraries
“This allowed a lot of people to make the difference between salesmanship and actual grounded results.”
Yannick Städler
Topic Librarian, University of Basel
“Information literacy has been kind of our bread and butter for decades in libraries… Our goal is to train students who can think for themselves.”

Chris Chan
University Librarian, Hong Kong Baptist University
“We can get to bigger fish to fry. We can get to the evaluation, the relevancy, the thinking about your topic, the how to think about information.”

Megan Heuer
Director of Educational Initiatives, SMU Libraries
“This allowed a lot of people to make the difference between salesmanship and actual grounded results.”
Yannick Städler
Topic Librarian, University of Basel
Discover how libraries are leading the conversation on AI.
00
Introduction: caught between prohibition and chaos
01
The state of AI in academic research
02
Why bans and silence both fail
03
We’ve done this before
04
Principles for a successful AI roll-out
05
In the classroom: five assignments
06
At the library: five case studies
07
A strategy for moving forward
A rough playbook for the first year
08
Reflections
—
Conclusion: Back at the reference desk
Discover how libraries are leading the conversation on AI.
00
Introduction: caught between prohibition and chaos
01
The state of AI in academic research
02
Why bans and silence both fail
03
We’ve done this before
04
Principles for a successful AI roll-out
05
In the classroom: five assignments
06
At the library: five case studies
07
A strategy for moving forward
A rough playbook for the first year
08
Reflections
—
Conclusion: Back at the reference desk
Discover how libraries are leading the conversation on AI.
00
Introduction: caught between prohibition and chaos
01
The state of AI in academic research
02
Why bans and silence both fail
03
We’ve done this before
04
Principles for a successful AI roll-out
05
In the classroom: five assignments
06
At the library: five case studies
07
A strategy for moving forward
A rough playbook for the first year
08
Reflections
—
Conclusion: Back at the reference desk
Before you download.
Who is this whitepaper for?
How was the research conducted?
Is the whitepaper free?
Consensus is a vendor. Is this a sales pitch?
Can Consensus walk our library through the findings?
Before you download.
Who is this whitepaper for?
How was the research conducted?
Is the whitepaper free?
Consensus is a vendor. Is this a sales pitch?
Can Consensus walk our library through the findings?
Before you download.
Who is this whitepaper for?
How was the research conducted?
Is the whitepaper free?
Consensus is a vendor. Is this a sales pitch?
Can Consensus walk our library through the findings?















Help your library lead on AI.

















