Effect of corruption of business performance
Pro Research Analysisby
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
The Effect of Corruption on Business Performance
Introduction to Corruption and Business Performance
Corruption is a pervasive issue that affects businesses worldwide, particularly in developing and emerging economies. The impact of corruption on business performance has been a subject of extensive research, with studies exploring whether corruption acts as a hindrance ("sands the wheels") or a facilitator ("greases the wheels") for business operations. This article synthesizes findings from multiple studies to provide a comprehensive understanding of how corruption influences business performance.
Negative Impact of Corruption on Firm Performance
General Findings Across Various Economies
Research consistently shows that corruption generally harms firm performance. A study analyzing 21,250 firms across 117 emerging and developing countries found that corruption negatively impacts firm performance, regardless of the proxy used for measurement. This negative impact is evident in various regions, including Latin America, the Caribbean, Eastern Europe, Central Asia, and Southern Asia, where corruption "sands the wheels" of business operations.
Specific Case Studies
In Nigeria, corruption and poor institutional quality were found to weaken both market value (TobinQ) and accounting value performance (ROA) of firms. Similarly, in Pakistan, corruption was shown to have a negative association with firm performance, particularly affecting younger, larger, and directly exporting firms. In Vietnam, corruption was found to deteriorate the financial performance of newly established enterprises, increasing their failure probability.
Mixed Effects and Contextual Variations
Regional and Firm-Specific Differences
While the general trend indicates a negative impact, some studies highlight contextual variations. For instance, corruption appears to "grease the wheels" for African firms, suggesting that in certain environments, corruption might facilitate business operations by bypassing bureaucratic hurdles. Additionally, larger and exporting firms in some regions may mitigate the negative effects of corruption more effectively.
Sectoral Differences
The impact of corruption also varies across different sectors. In Nigeria, non-financial firms suffer more from corruption and weak institutional environments compared to financial institutions, likely due to less regulatory oversight. In Greece, the negative impact of corrupt business practices on organizational performance was found to be significantly stronger than the impact of corrupt practices by employees.
Positive Impact of Anti-Corruption Measures
Evidence from Vietnam
Anti-corruption campaigns can significantly improve business performance. In Vietnam, an ongoing high-profile anti-corruption campaign positively impacted the performance of private firms by enhancing institutional quality and financial transparency. However, the same campaign had a negative impact on firms with state ownership, indicating that anti-corruption measures can have varied effects depending on the ownership structure of firms.
General Observations
Studies from Saudi Arabia also support the notion that anti-corruption efforts positively influence firm performance. Strong anti-corruption measures were found to have a significant positive effect on business operations, suggesting that efforts to curb corruption can lead to better business outcomes.
Conclusion
The relationship between corruption and business performance is complex and context-dependent. While the general consensus is that corruption negatively impacts firm performance, there are instances where it may temporarily facilitate business operations in highly bureaucratic environments. However, the long-term benefits of anti-corruption measures are clear, as they improve institutional quality and transparency, ultimately leading to better business performance. Policymakers and business leaders should focus on implementing robust anti-corruption frameworks to foster a healthier business environment.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic