How do we reconcile quantum mechanics with classical physics?
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
Reconciling Quantum Mechanics with Classical Physics
Reconciling quantum mechanics with classical physics is a fundamental challenge in modern physics. This article explores various approaches and theories that aim to bridge the gap between these two realms.
Quantum-Classical Mixing and Equations of Motion
One approach to reconciling quantum mechanics with classical physics involves the development of quantum-classical hybrid dynamics. A group-theoretical approach has been used to derive a quantum-classical equation of motion that preserves the Lie algebra structure of both quantum and classical mechanics. This formalism allows for a natural description of interactions between quantum and classical degrees of freedom, and has been applied to coupled quantum and classical oscillators. Additionally, linear dynamics of quantum-classical hybrids have been formulated, which are of interest for quantum mechanical approximation schemes and foundational experiments exploring the quantum-classical border.
No-Collapse Interpretations and Classical Appearances
Another perspective is provided by no-collapse interpretations of quantum mechanics, such as those combining aspects of Bohmian mechanics and the many-worlds interpretation. These theories reproduce the empirical predictions of quantum mechanics while appearing surprisingly classical at a fundamental level, with particles interacting via Newtonian forces and no wave function. This approach suggests that classical physics can emerge from quantum mechanics under certain interpretations.
Post-Quantum Theories and Macroscopic Limits
Some researchers propose that reconciling quantum mechanics with general relativity may require abandoning the quantum formalism in favor of a more general theory. Such post-quantum theories should recover classical physics in the macroscopic limit, providing a mechanism to bound the strength of correlations between distant observers and suggesting the existence of microscopic theories predicting correlations beyond quantum mechanical systems.
Classical Entanglement and Optics
The similarities between quantum mechanics and paraxial optics have long been recognized, with quantum mechanical methods being employed to better understand optics. The concept of classical entanglement has emerged, raising questions about which quantum tasks could be implemented with classical light. This cross-fertilization between quantum mechanics and classical optics provides a framework for exploring the classical-quantum divide.
Experimental Evidence and Non-Classicality
Experimental evidence has shown that certain properties in quantum systems cannot be simultaneously well-defined, as demonstrated by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Experiments with single photonic qutrits have provided evidence that no joint probability distribution describing the outcomes of all possible measurements can exist, illustrating a deep incompatibility between quantum mechanics and classical physics.
Classical Interpretation of Quantum Concepts
Efforts to interpret quantum mechanical concepts within a classical framework have also been made. For instance, Einstein's methods have been used to establish a logical connection with classical theory by requiring that observables be described in a physically-defined coordinate system and adhering to the conservation of momentum. This approach replaces the abstract space of quantum mechanics with a real classical space.
Quantum-Classical Mechanics in Molecular Physics
In molecular and chemical physics, the dynamics of quantum transitions involve the joint motion of light electrons and heavy nuclei. To address the singularities in time-dependent perturbation theory, a method called dozy-chaos mechanics has been proposed. This approach introduces chaos during molecular quantum transitions, leading to a continuity of the energy spectrum in the transient state, which is a sign of classical mechanics.
Historical and Conceptual Perspectives
The relationship between classical and quantum theory has been a central topic in the philosophy of physics. Historical and conceptual analyses have shown that certain ideas, such as Heisenberg's reinterpretation of classical observables and Bohr's correspondence principle, continue to be important in understanding classical behavior from quantum mechanics. Various limits, such as the small Planck's constant limit and the large system limit, have been explored to understand how classical physics emerges from quantum mechanics.
Conclusion
Reconciling quantum mechanics with classical physics involves a multifaceted approach, including hybrid dynamics, no-collapse interpretations, post-quantum theories, and experimental evidence. By exploring these various perspectives, researchers aim to bridge the gap between the quantum and classical worlds, providing a deeper understanding of the fundamental nature of reality.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic