What is the rise of populism in Europe?
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Consensus Meter
The Rise of Populism in Europe
Introduction to European Populism
Populism has seen a significant rise across Europe over the past few decades, influencing both political landscapes and party systems. This phenomenon is characterized by a growing divide between populist and anti-populist forces, each presenting different visions of democracy and governance.
Causes of Populism in Europe
Erosion of Representative Democracy
One of the primary drivers of populism in Europe is the perceived erosion of the representative function of traditional party systems. This has led to what some scholars describe as a "partyless democracy," where traditional parties fail to represent the electorate effectively, paving the way for unmediated populist protests. This erosion is linked to broader structural trends and societal conflicts that have not been adequately addressed by mainstream parties.
Economic Factors and Growth Regimes
Economic factors also play a crucial role in the rise of populism. The literature on growth regimes suggests that conflicts between debtors and creditors have fueled populist movements. However, this explanation is not entirely sufficient, as populist movements in some European countries predate the global financial crisis and subsequent austerity measures. The inability of traditional parties to respond effectively to economic crises has further exacerbated the situation.
Reaction to Undemocratic Liberalism
Populism is often seen as an illiberal democratic response to what is perceived as undemocratic liberalism. This perspective argues that populism arises from real and perceived crises, serving as a catalyst rather than the primary cause. The solution to populism, according to this view, lies in enhancing liberal democracy rather than diminishing it.
Populist Parties and Their Impact
Programmatic Contagion
Contrary to the belief that populism is contagious among political parties, research indicates that mainstream parties in Western Europe have not significantly adopted populist rhetoric in their programs. Instead, it is the populist parties themselves that moderate their positions after initial success. This suggests that while populist parties influence the political discourse, they do not necessarily cause mainstream parties to become more populist.
Populism and Nationalism
The rise of populism is often conflated with nationalism and nativism. In Western Europe, populist parties frequently frame their opposition in broader civilizational terms, particularly against perceived threats from Islam. This has led to a form of "civilizationism" that combines identitarian Christianism with secularist and liberal rhetoric, challenging traditional understandings of national populism.
The Populism/Anti-Populism Divide
The divide between populism and anti-populism is becoming increasingly antagonistic. Populists advocate for a radical, popular form of democracy, while anti-populists support a more liberal democratic framework. This divide is not just about differing political ideologies but also about fundamentally different conceptions of how democracy should function in Europe.
Conclusion
The rise of populism in Europe is a multifaceted phenomenon driven by the erosion of traditional party systems, economic conflicts, and reactions to perceived undemocratic liberalism. While populist parties have significantly influenced political discourse, their impact on mainstream party programs is limited. The ongoing divide between populist and anti-populist forces continues to shape the European political landscape, highlighting the need for a more nuanced understanding of this complex issue.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic